... Well now

Close

... Well now

Published: Nov 20, 2015
Share this blog post with your friends!
View 25 Comments

... Isn't it interesting how a little communications leads to more communications!  Feedback!!  Thank you all for your comments.  On the signature line of each email I send is the following anonymous quote:  Everyone you meet is fighting a battle you know nothing about.  Be kind.  Always.  Just a reminder that as Scouters we are all obligated to live by the spirit of the Scout Oath and Law and to lift one another up, while providing direct feedback, so that every day we can improve the Scouting for the youth of America.

So my last blog post (and several before that) have evoked many requests to know what the development roadmap for Scoutbook will be.  Anyone who has brought a complex product to market (software or otherwise) while keeping the wheels spinning knows how risky projecting milestones is.  Never-the-less, in the spirit of openness, I'm going to lay out the priorities for the Scoutbook development team over the next three months, which is as far as I can see with clarity at this time.  As you review these priorities, please remember three things –

1) The resources are what the resources are.  While Boy Scouts of America is investing significantly in the development of Scoutbook, there are some wishes that will not be realized and some that will not happen as fast as we all would like.  

2) We are building Scoutbook for the future of the youth and leaders of Scouting.  Sometimes this is going to mean we will be developing "stories" (to use the agile term) that do not in the short term appear to have clear user value but will be cornerstones of future functionality (this is particularly true of the building steps to full integration with BSA's person database, Akela – aka ScoutNet or PAS, the place for all advancement, awards, training, etc.).

3) There will be dedicated resources assigned to each of these priorities so don't think of them as having an order, they are all important.

4) Okay, four things.  The priorities are informed by the following:  data on site performance and usage, the user community’s forum and blog posts, consultation with the Scoutbook User Advisory Council of volunteers, advice and guidance from Shawn Jackson (Scoutbook creator and user advocate), Asynchrony (our software development partner) and BSA’s system admin and database resources.  In the final analysis, however, the priorities are my direction to the team so all credit to the team, all criticism to me.

So, with those thoughts:

Priority

Comments

CS/BS implementation and User Valued Enhancements

 

Completion of new Cub Scout program awards and functionality within Scoutbook, preparation for 1/2016 launch of new Boy Scout requirements.  Enhancements to the calendar, payment log, messaging, etc.

Site Performance

 

Actions to speed site responsiveness/load times.  SQL query optimization, parameterization, database maintenance jobs, etc.

COPPA Compliance and YPT Adherence

 

COPPA - Federal law outlines required processes to authenticate a parent’s permission for under 13 year olds to have online accounts.  Assuring that all communications with youth members involves more than one adult.

Customer service support and site experience

 

Impacting new and learning users a “self-help” area is being developed to support a series of videos Shawn Jackson is preparing, consolidating FAQs (in addition to the “tips” that appear throughout the site), etc.

NET Authentication – Akela Integration Roadmap

Technical roadmap to true integration of Scoutbook with BSA’s person database.  Initially will not affect the user experience, later will integrate Scoutbook and my.scouting login.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

What I have outlined, and the team has committed to, is an aggressive vision, one which we believe will support users of all “calibers” and move Scoutbook forward.  As always, feedback is welcome.

BTW, this IS THE FRIDAY BLOG (@Craig Mielke).  This week we released a fix to the phantom pack meeting that many of you may have received notice of (I hope the meeting went well and the boys had a great time) and four SQL optimizations intended to speed loading of the dashboard and other high volume pages.  Initial results suggest that, while effective, those fixes “uncovered” other performance opportunities – which we are perusing.

TTFN and have a great weekend.

  • Comments (25)
  • Mayflower Council Image
    Assistant Scoutmaster
    10 years ago
    Doug DeMeritt
    Is there away to work on major enhancements or changes in Scout Book while at least providing some minor user experience changes at the same time. One thing is recurring events in the calendar and allowing the attendance report to be downloaded (Pretty picture that can't even be printed) or quick entry for payments. I get the play nice I am patient but bringing something to market this is a product that is integrated with the program right now provided by BSA so you have your market share where other scouting tracking products can't claim that status, thanks.
    Pending Approval
  • Westmoreland Fayette Image
    10 years ago
    Greg Capasso
    Thanks for the update but I think many of the users including myself are still trying to understand what is being worked on exactly. A consolidated list of bugs and features would be a great start with a status next to each item. As new items are added they could be appended to the list. For example the simple process of getting a listing of what items within all new adventures for a cub scout rank that have been completed or not for all the scouts in that den. This is a feature that has previously worked until the new requirements were entered and now the functionality no longer exists. I have no idea if this is something that is going to be fixed or functionality returned. I have submitted e-mails and posted on the forums along with many others but I still have no idea if this is something that is going to be addressed. In the mean time we are forced to guess if something is going to work and try to find work arounds (which there are none) since not even exports are working for the new requirements. I have been a huge supporter of scoutbook and have even helped other packs and troops get things running, but with the way things currently are working I no longer feel confortable recommending the product.
    I am a software developer by trade and I do understand the frustration and headaches your team is facing but you also need to understand our frustration using a product we pay for where we are no longer able to do the things we purchased it for in the first place.
    I know things take time and we all understand that but very open discussion with details needs to presented. This is not a beta software. This is a product we paid for and use daily. A task as simple as the report I mentioned above now takes almost 45 minutes to go into 18 scouts for our one den and take screenshots of all there advancements to match that same functionality that previously worked.
    I also ask that is some of these things such as reports are going to take a while, please fix the export functionality so we can at least get a flat file of the data so we can create our own reports outside the application.
    Pending Approval
  • Washington Crossing Council Image
    Committee Chairman
    10 years ago
    Stephen Hornak
    @Greg - I see you are in the Greensburg area, if you ever happen to be near the Barnhart Funeral Home, stop by and tell Mark and Jeff that I said Hi and that I still remember those whitewater rafting trips on the Yough.
    updated 10 years ago
    Pending Approval
  • Washington Crossing Council Image
    Committee Chairman
    10 years ago
    Scott Fisher
    Doug and Greg, these are great pieces of input and very valid points. Better use of the Change-log moving forward should be a key consideration as the great progress that the BSA has now outlined above takes place. Scoutbook Users need to be able to follow along with what is being accomplished.

    Bob has requested that the discussion for this important blog post continue on over in the Forums this week. This way, Scoutbook Users can SUBSCRIBE to the Forum Thread and stay more up-to-date on discussions and conversations on the FUTURE of Scoutbook. Rome may not have been built in a day -- BUT -- as someone who has closely followed the progress (and frustrations) of Scoutbook Development for years, I can say confidently that having now seen the above timeline and just how many departments of the BSA are being incorporated into these plans, there is MUCH GOOD WORK TO DO and all of our help and input will be needed.

    The link for the Forum Thread where ALL Comments for this Blog should move over to is:

    Since BB Code does not work in this blog reply, simply COPY AND PASTE to use the following link in your browser:

    https://www.scoutbook.com/mobile/forums/using-scoutbook/54914/official-bsa-scoutbook-timeline--bob-s-blog---2015-11-20-/
    updated 10 years ago
    Pending Approval
  • Washington Crossing Council Image
    Committee Chairman
    10 years ago
    Scott Fisher
    There are technical aspects of that we were not able to alter and Bob's message is of utmost importance to Scoutbook's Users and he did not want to delay that message. We are looking into that but unable to do so right now.

    So, Steve, looking forward to some great conversation over at the Forum Thread. There are SOME items not prioritized yet (we are voicing the support for Venturing regularly, for example) but we want to CELEBRATE some of the break-throughs that are coming in the near future and then work toward support of even more in the mid-term to long-term future.

    See you at:

    https://www.scoutbook.com/mobile/forums/using-scoutbook/54914/official-bsa-scoutbook-timeline--bob-s-blog---2015-11-20-/
    updated 10 years ago
    Pending Approval
  • Great Salt Lake Council Image
    10 years ago
    Dave Neeley
    There's a Scoutbook Advisory Council? :) Cool. And development on Scoutbook is being done by a third party? Didn't know that either. Transparency is much appreciated!
    Pending Approval
  • Greater Alabama Council Image
    10 years ago
    Lora King
    Thanks, Bob!
    Pending Approval
  • Greater St. Louis Area Council Image
    10 years ago
    Timothy Schilling
    Asynchrony is actually a company here in St. Louis which is located in downtown. Cool to know this is happening in my backyard!
    Pending Approval
  • Cradle Of Liberty Council Image
    10 years ago
    Peg Doman
    This is an exciting program that brings all of we, the antique's of yesteryear scouting, into the 21st century. As a parent/grandparent of a youngster it enlightens me to the concepts in Boy Scouting that are new to me. Thank you
    Pending Approval
  • Washington Crossing Council Image
    Committee Chairman
    10 years ago
    Scott Fisher
    Peg, it is very cool that Scoutbook allows the entire family to follow the Scouts' Scouting careers!. I know that my son's "pop-pop" probably checks Scoutbook as often as my son does!

    Dave, nice to know that all of the Voices of the Scoutbook Users are being accounted for, right? In a volunteer-led organization, User input is very important so Bob Scott's Team can make the best decisions to move Scoutbook forward into the future.

    Join us over at the link below for more discussion like this though. ONLY the link below will allow you to SUBSCRIBE TO the responses so you can follow the conversation. The Scoutbook Blog Area does not have that capability (at least not yet).

    https://www.scoutbook.com/mobile/forums/using-scoutbook/54914/official-bsa-scoutbook-timeline--bob-s-blog---2015-11-20-/
    Pending Approval
  • Connecticut Yankee Council BSA Image
    Committee Member
    10 years ago
    Jeff Vilenski
    Thanks for the update.
    Pending Approval
  • Montana Council Image
    Committee Chairman
    Trained Strip
    10 years ago
    Lora Hall
    Do you have an eta for Venturing?
    Pending Approval
  • Simon Kenton Council Image
    10 years ago
    Anthony Cuttitta
    Scoutbook -- on the surface -- seems simple, but the more I delve into it, the more I'm astounded by how much thought has been put into it. I was a developer for a long time and have made a few massive databases to keep track of things (or at least inherited the maintenance of ones created by others), and I must say...the scope of this project is staggering. The user base is growing exponentially as word gets out and that's just complicating issues.

    Hats off to the team working on this and I'm excited to see what's to come!
    Pending Approval
  • San Diego Imperial Council Image
    Assistant Scoutmaster
    Trained Strip
    10 years ago
    Scouter Barb Sigsworth
    Thank you for the update!
    Pending Approval
  • Greater Alabama Council Image
    10 years ago
    Margaret Chalmers
    Nice toggles!!!
    Pending Approval
  • Heart of America Council Image
    Assistant Scoutmaster
    10 years ago
    Nils Erickson
    I was wondering if you have any information on the Venturing Module. It was supposed to be out in March ...then June and now? I know Ventures is not that high a priority but the program would make it easier for the crew to do their own administration instead of a series of excel spreadsheets. Especially since most of the members do most of their work on smartphones and not e-mails and spreadsheets.
    Pending Approval
  • Natchez Trace Council Image
    Committee Chairman
    10 years ago
    Heather Fulton
    Thanks for all the updates. Do we know when the Nova will be updated to the new program? Still references "Pins" and does not have the new available awards (Out of this World).
    updated 10 years ago
    Pending Approval
  • Northeast Iowa Council Image
    Scoutmaster
    10 years ago
    Jon Uzel
    Is there currently any plans to add anything at a district/council level for leadership entries and such? I know this had been part of the plan quite some time ago, but I've not seen anything recently.
    Pending Approval
  • Lake Erie Council Image
    Assistant Scoutmaster
    10 years ago
    Rob Kuehn
    was hoping for Adult Awards to be available to be posted ie service knots, past Eagle Scouts, etc ?
    Pending Approval
  • Utah National Parks Image
    10 years ago
    Kathleen Speckhard
    Where do I find the Payment Log option?
    Pending Approval
  • The Spirit of Adventure Image
    9 years ago
    Paul Franklin
    My apologies if this was mentioned specifically, but I only found a vague mention of messaging enhancements.
    Are there any plans to archive outgoing messages? While always remembering to send to myself is a solution, having messages archived in Scoutbook would be ideal.
    Pending Approval
  • Grand Canyon Council Image
    Assistant Scoutmaster
    9 years ago
    Robert Cranney
    @Bob Scott, @Shawn Jackson

    It's been more than the 3 month, since you provided a 3 month road map. Would you be so kind as to communicate an update on the road map priorities...

    Having worked on Agile projects, I understand the challenges with delivering complex projects, but part of being a product owner / Scout Leader in my estimation is be open about reality.
    I don't think I am alone in wishing for more communication / visibility.

    Yours in scouting,
    Robert Cranney
    Pending Approval
  • Buckskin Image
    Scoutmaster
    9 years ago
    Teresa Dove
    Could you give an update on this blog? I noticed that the STEM Awards still haven't been updated (I had one kid do the Out of this World requirements and still cannot enter it into Scoutbook). Thank you so much for all that you do!
    Pending Approval
  • Potawatomi Area Council Image
    9 years ago
    Matthew Mertens
    Let me begin with a message of gratitude for the advancements being made in Scoutbook. Thank you.

    With regard to the above list of priorities, I also would much appreciate an update on the progress of these identified priorities. As we are in the flux between high activity portions of the year and fundraisers, the update to the payment log would be much appreciated. we are trying to move away from an independent payment log and now is the perfect time of the year to make this transition, but the current log in scout book just does not cut it. could you please provide an update on when the payment log advancements will occur and if possible, what those advancements might be? Priorities to make this workable for a pack includes an administrators need to log/ charge payments due and credits to accounts from a ledger so you don't have to go into each scouts account individually. With over 60 scouts, one at a time entry is time prohibitive.

    Thank you in advance for any updates you may be able to provide.
    If the answer is, nothing will be done, that will help me to plan as well. Thanks
    Matt
    Pending Approval
  • Longs Peak Council Image
    Committee Member
    7 years ago
    Kelly Alberts
    Would love to see the new Payments log placed into the Quick Entry. When a new trip is coming up, that would allow us to quickly add the amount to all scouts going. Or even payment. Also, would love to see some additional enhancements to the calendar: Ability to copy or duplicate from one date to another, Ability to have an event repeated, Ability to add a permission form or file to the calendar. Finally, the code to the calendar needs to be fixed when someone chooses all scouts. If a new scout is added, the calendar is NOT smart enough to add that scout. That is a huge pain, for every event already created, we have to go in manually and add that scout/family. The calendar should be smart enough to add them automatically if you picked "all" during the creation of it.
    Pending Approval

Delete Comment?

Are you sure you want to delete your comment?

This action cannot be undone.